Schlage Encode Plus Review: Is This Smart Lock Worth the Premium Price?
The Bottom Line: If you are looking for an honest Schlage Encode Plus Review, here is the short version: The Schlage Encode Plus is an excellent choice for those deeply invested in the Apple HomeKit ecosystem, offering robust security and convenient Home Key access. While its battery life can be a minor concern, its seamless integration and durable design make it a top contender in the ideal smart lock category.
The Claim vs. The Reality
Manufacturers often paint a perfect picture. We cut through the noise to see where the Schlage Encode Plus truly shines and where its marketing might stretch the truth.
- The Good: The Schlage Encode Plus is genuinely an anticipated 2025 model, poised for enhanced Matter protocol support and improved battery management, promising truly seamless smart home integration. Its durable metal construction and advanced encryption aren’t just buzzwords; they deliver tangible security and longevity. The standout feature, however, is its Apple Home Key integration, allowing you to unlock your door with a tap of your iPhone or Apple Watch – a feature few competitors can match.
- The Bad: While improved battery management is on the horizon, the current reality for many users is inconsistent battery life, especially with frequent use and continuous Wi-Fi connectivity. This isn’t a deal-breaker, but it means you might be changing batteries more often than you’d like, which can be a minor inconvenience for a device designed for ultimate convenience.
The Field Test
Imagine this: You’re juggling groceries, kids, and your phone, arriving home after a long day. With the Schlage Encode Plus, there’s no fumbling for keys. As you approach, your iPhone or Apple Watch, thanks to Apple Home Key, is ready. A simple tap, and the door unlocks, granting you effortless entry. Inside, the lock integrates flawlessly with your HomeKit setup, allowing you to check its status, grant temporary access to a dog walker, or lock up remotely, all from the intuitive Home app. The Matter protocol support ensures it plays well with other smart devices, making your smart home truly interconnected without compatibility headaches.
The Compromises (The Cons)
No product is perfect, and the Schlage Encode Plus, while excellent, has a few trade-offs to consider before you commit.
- Inconsistent Battery Life: As noted, the most common complaint revolves around the battery. While Schlage aims for improvement, current models can drain batteries faster than expected, particularly in high-traffic homes or areas with weaker Wi-Fi signals. This means more frequent battery changes, which can interrupt the seamless experience the lock otherwise provides.
- Full Deadbolt Replacement Required: Unlike some retrofit options, the Schlage Encode Plus requires a full replacement of your existing deadbolt. While installation is generally straightforward for DIYers, it’s a more involved process than simply adding a smart module to your current lock. This might be a deterrent for renters or those who prefer a less invasive upgrade.
Final Verdict: Who Should Buy This?
Green Light (Buy It): If you are an Apple HomeKit user looking for the most seamless and secure smart lock experience, especially with Apple Home Key integration, the Schlage Encode Plus is the best value on the market. It’s also ideal for homeowners who prioritize robust security, durable construction, and future-proof Matter compatibility.
Red Light (Upgrade Instead): If you are a renter who can’t replace your deadbolt, or if an absolutely invisible aesthetic is your top priority, you might find yourself wanting more. Similarly, if you’re on a very tight budget and only need basic smart lock functionality, this model might be overkill.
Check Best Price on Amazon
The Alternatives
Not sold on the Schlage Encode Plus? Here is how it stacks up against the competition.
If you are on a tight budget, the August Wi-Fi Smart Lock is a fantastic alternative. Priced around $199, it offers essential smart lock features without requiring you to replace your entire deadbolt, making it a cost-effective retrofit solution. You can find it on Amazon here.
If you need pro-level power and an unparalleled aesthetic, consider the Level Lock+. This premium option, around $499, boasts an invisible design that maintains your home’s original look, combined with robust security and Apple Home Key integration. Its hidden motor and high-grade materials offer a truly discreet smart lock experience. Check it out on Amazon here.